EB Industries has been welding Titanium for over 50 years utilizing both laser welding and EB welding technologies. This page describes some of the challenges of laser welding titanium and how the experts at EB Industries overcome them.
The Challenges of Welding Titanium
Titanium is a light weight metal with excellent corrosion resistance and the highest strength-to-density ratio of any metallic element. It’s a great material for many applications, from super light weight aerospace parts to artificial joints to implanted medical devices.
Titanium has two properties that greatly influence its weldability: 1) Titanium has a great chemical affinity for combining with oxygen; and 2) Titanium doesn’t have a great affinity for combining with any other chemicals.
In open air, freshly machined or cleaned titanium quickly forms a microscopic layer of oxides. This formation of oxides creates a natural passivity that inhibits the reactions with other chemicals, such as salt or oxidizing acid solutions. The result is that titanium has superior corrosion resistance. However, when heated for welding, these oxides form even faster, and as the temperature reaches titanium’s melting point (1668 °C, 3034 °F), the oxides dissolve into solution and contaminate the weld pool, causing an impure and very weak weld. For this reason, special care must be taken to minimize the weld piece’s exposure to oxygen after cleaning and during welding. Generally, a shield gas such as argon or helium is used to protect the part, and special care must be taken to make sure the gas completely covers the heat affected area including the back side and/or interior of the part. One option that provides exceptional gas coverage would be to weld the part in a laser welding glove box filled with pure gas. Parts can also be reliably welded in a full vacuum (as is the case with electron beam welding), however, laser welding in a vacuum not widely available.
Since titanium is a very nonreactive substance, it is an excellent material for use in medical applications in which it will be in extended contact with human tissue, because chemicals and compounds within the body simply don’t bond with titanium. However, this characteristic also means that titanium does not easily alloy with other materials, which makes it almost impossible to weld titanium to any other metal. Hence, it is not recommended to use titanium in any dissimilar material welding application. If bonding titanium to another metal is essential to an application, explosion bonding or certain types of brazing would be the only viable options.
Recommended Lasers for Titanium Welding
There are four main categories of lasers that are suitable for welding Titanium:
- Nd:YAG (Neodymium: Yttrium-Aluminum-Garnet)
- Fiber (generally Ytterbium doped)
- Disk (Yb:YAG ytterbium)
All of the above laser types are suitable for welding titanium, and the choice of method is mainly depended on operational costs rather than any issues of weld quality. Each process does have different characteristics which can make some types of lasers preferable for certain applications and joint configurations.
Pulsed vs Continuous Wave Laser Welding
There are two basic ways to operate the laser during titanium welding, as either a series of pulses or as continuous beam.
A pulsed laser beam is switched on and off during the welding process at a frequency somewhere between 10-1000 Hz, such that the energy is applied to the joining area in a series of discrete pulses. The work piece is moved under the beam, the result of which is overlapped discrete welds creating a continuous weld bead. The pulsed nature of the beam ensures that the amount of energy flowing into area surrounding the weld isn’t excessive, thus minimizing the potential for heat deformation of the part.
In continuous wave laser welding, the beam is applied steady state and either moved across the work piece or held stationary while the work piece is moved. A keyhole type weld is created as the titanium at the leading edge melts while the trailing edge cools. To avoid heat deformation of the part, continuous wave lasers need to feed at speeds from 25 to 100 inches per minute, far too fast for safe and accurate manual laser welding.
Titanium can be welded with either a pulsed or continuous wave process. Pulsed laser welding is preferable for shallow welds where minimal heat input is desired. Continuous wave laser welding is more appropriate if the application requires a greater depth of penetration.
Laser Welding Titanium
Laser beam welding is a good option for welding titanium. If part cleaning and gas cover are handled properly, the process will yield high quality welds at a reasonable cost. Typically, laser welding penetration can range up to 0.325” in titanium.
Cover Gases for Titanium Welding
Cover gases are absolutely required when laser welding titanium. As mentioned previously, special care should be taken to insure the heated area of the part are completely covered with gas. Simply directing a gas nozzle in the area of the weld will not provide adequate coverage. Special tooling or fixtures should be utilized to completely flood the weld and surrounding area with gas. A pure gas laser welding glove box is the optimal setup for welding titanium.
Choices of cover gases are limited:
- Argon: the relatively low cost of the gas make it the first choice for most titanium laser welding applications. Additionally, because it is slightly heavier than air, Argon is easy to direct and cover a part — Argon tends to stay in the weld zone.
- Helium: generally not recommended due to its high cost. Helium is considerably lighter than air, making it difficult to contain and direct. However, helium cover gas tends to provide a hotter weld pool, allowing for potentially deeper penetration.
- Argon-Helium Mixtures: generally recommended when a range of characteristics is required by the application.
Titanium is a hard metal, so special machining precautions during fabrication are not necessarily required, but as with all precision welding applications, special care must be taken to remove oxides and hydrocarbon contamination from titanium parts before welding. This is can be achieved mechanically, using stainless steel wire brushes, grinding, filing or scraping to remove any oxides. There are also chemical cleaning methods utilizing immersions in caustic solutions and water that are effective at removing oxides.
Hydrocarbon residue on titanium parts is usually removed using acetone or alcohol based solvents. Avoid using chlorinated solvents in the welding area because they can form toxic gases when heated.
Titanium parts should be welded immediately after cleaning. If this isn’t possible, parts can be sealed in plastic bags back filled with dry argon or nitrogen to avoid having to repeat the cleaning process.
Joint Prep Guidelines
- When cleaning a surface with solvents, use clean cloth such as cheese cloth or paper towels. Do not use shop rags that may be contaminated with oil residue.
- Use a stainless steel wire brush to clean a joint only after solvent cleaning. Wire brushing prior may embed hydrocarbons and other contaminates.
- Always use a new or recently cleaned stainless steel brushes to clean a joint. Older brushes sitting around a work bench may contain oils and other contaminates. Do not use brushes that have been used on other metals as metal flakes can be carried on the brush bristles and cause contamination and weak welds.
- Use a stainless steel wire brush to clean any metal surface that has been etched. By-product residuals from etching can alter the chemical composition of the weld pool, resulting in a weak weld.
- Clean all wire brushes and cutting tools frequently.
- Avoid using compressed shop air to blow off debris from the area of the joint. Compressed air contains moisture and oil contaminates. If a part must be blown off, use a bottled gas such as nitrogen or argon.
Laser welding requires a precise joint in order to maintain permissible gap and avoid mismatch. Good weld fixturing is necessary so that the laser beam can be placed accurately. Of course, the most accurate laser welds happen when beam placement and welding process are computer rather than manually controlled.
- Butt Weld:
- A fit-up tolerance of 15% of the material thickness is desirable.
- Sheared edges are acceptable provided they are straight and square.
- Misalignment and out-of-flatness of parts should be less than 25% of the material thickness.
- Lap Weld (burn-through or seam weld):
- Air gaps between pieces to be Lap Joint welded severely limit weld penetration and/or feed speed.
- For round welds in titanium, no gap can be tolerated unless inert gas coverage can be maintained over the entire weld area.
- Fillet Weld:
- Square edges and good fit-up are also necessary.
Engineering Consultation and Quotations
We know the best solutions come from collaboration with our customers, and our engineering staff is available to you right at the beginning of your design process. Call now to consult with an engineer about your application at 1-631-293-8565, or fill out an online quotation request. There are also many technical resources available on our website.
Take advantage of the experience and know how that is the hallmark of EB Industries.